I am glad that I have finally read this novel, which had so much attention when it first was published that I actually decided to avoid it for awhile.
Two lines anchored this book for me. The first is one spoken by an elderly man who tells the future writer of Pi's story that it is "a story to make you believe in God." That's quite a high standard to set at the beginning of a novel.
Pi Patel is Christian, Muslim, and Hindu. (Seriously - he devoutely practices all three religions!) The Life of Pi is, at its core, a story of religion and a story of survival. Perhaps, also, it is a story about stories.
"And so it goes with God." That is the second anchoring line, which comes at the very end of the book.
Reading the ending, knowing that Pi's story was to "make me believe in God," I was waiting for the "wow" sensation as a I closed the last page. It didn't come. Rather, I have lots of questions, conjectures, and a need to re-read this book in a few months to examine the details more closely.
For now, here is my speculation [mild spoiler alert]. Pi himself is a contradiction, practising multiple religions with extraordinary devotion. He endures intense loss and suffering, but his faith and industry enable him to survive. In the end, when Japanese investigators meet with him to discover how he survived, they don't believe his tale. So he retells it, replacing the animal characters with human ones. The revised story is barely readable for its brutality. At the end, he asks the investigators which they prefer. They reply that they prefer the one with animals. "And so it goes with God." Does that mean that only God knows what story is true? Or does it mean that whatever story is pleasing to us - whatever religion - is how we engage with our God? In other words, "And so it goes with God" could be translated as "the same is true for God." I'm still thinking...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Hi Katie! Enjoying your blog! I put off reading this post until recently, as I was still working on Life of Pi, but I am finally finished! I so agree with your review. My biggest sensation upon concluding this novel is - "huh?" - followed by " I have to go back and read it again. I have tried looking online for stuff from the author, but even that is kind of cryptic. The author's note at the beginning, for example - is it fictional? Is the author of this story an additional character? I am confused and will also re-read this in a few months.
I am definitely pondering your thoughts about "and so it goes with God" - whichever story suits you best? It is interesting. Hmmm...Let me know when you do re-read.
Up next - Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez and then, Stones From the River...
Ever read them?
Katie - When I read Life of Pi, I never made a connection between his practicing three religions and his telling two versions of the same story. Your interpretation makes a lot of sense to me. Thank you, because I have been feeling like I missed something!
Post a Comment